Diving into ERC-7512: Standardizing On-Chain Audit Representation for Ethereum Smart Contracts

4 min readFeb 12, 2024

This article comprehensively analyzes ERC-7512, a proposed Ethereum standard aiming to bring smart contract audits on-chain for increased transparency and trust. It delves into the potential benefits and challenges of this innovative approach.

In the ever-evolving world of Decentralized Finance (DeFi), smart contract security remains a paramount concern. While audits offer a crucial layer of assurance, their accessibility and interpretability often leave room for improvement. Enter ERC-7512, a proposed Ethereum standard aiming to revolutionize how audit reports are represented and utilized. This article delves into the technical specifics of ERC-7512, exploring its purpose, key features, and potential impact on the DeFi landscape.

Born from a Need for Transparency

Ethereum Request for Comments or ERC-7512 was initially proposed in July 2023 by a collaborative effort led by Richard Meissner (Safe), Robert Chen (OtterSec), Matthias Egli (ChainSecurity), Ackee Blockchain, OpenZeppelin and Hats.finance. Their primary motivation stemmed from the inherent limitations of traditional audit reports:

Limited accessibility

Reports primarily reside on centralized platforms, accessible only to select individuals.

Lack of standardization

Diverse report formats hinder consistency and automated analysis.

Potential for manipulation

Off-chain storage leaves them vulnerable to alteration.

Building a Trustworthy Foundation

ERC-7512 outlines a standardized on-chain representation for audit reports to address these issues. This structure facilitates various advantages:

Transparency

Audit information becomes readily accessible and tamper-proof on the blockchain.

Machine-readability

Standardized data empowers smart contracts to verify audit details automatically.

Interoperability

A consistent format enables effortless integration with DeFi protocols and tools.

Technical Deep Dive

The core of ERC-7512 lies in its defined data structure, encompassing essential fields like:

Audit properties

Auditor identity, contract address, audit date, and standards checked.

Methodology

Details of the auditing approach and techniques employed.

Findings

Identified vulnerabilities and their severity levels.

Remediation steps

Recommendations for addressing discovered vulnerabilities.

Proposed Proxy Addition

The current follow-up explores challenges in handling proxies, a crucial component of the Ethereum ecosystem.
The choice between deploymentCode and runtimeCode for representing the underlying implementation is a key debate.
While runtimeCode offers easier retrieval, it lacks constructor logic and arguments, raising security concerns.
deploymentCode includes constructor logic but is more challenging to retrieve and still lacks constructor arguments.
A lack of constructor arguments can introduce vulnerabilities, especially in factory contracts.
Two approaches are proposed for codifying constructor arguments:

Pre-deployment Auditor Verification

Auditors hash constructor arguments for comparison with post-deployment data.

Post-deployment Auditor Verification

Human-readable constructor arguments are linked to initialization transactions.

This structured format leverages ERC-7512 for secure signing and verification, ensuring data integrity and authenticity.

A Glimpse into the Future

With its potential to enhance trust and automate security checks, ERC-7512 holds significant promise for the future of DeFi. Here’s how it could revolutionize the landscape:

Smart contract verification

Protocols can automatically assess security based on on-chain audit data.

Decentralized insurance

Insurance protocols can leverage audit information for risk assessment and underwriting decisions.

Improved user experience

Users gain immediate access to detailed audit reports, empowering informed investment choices.

Challenges and Considerations

However, it’s essential to acknowledge the challenges and considerations surrounding ERC-7512:

Complexity

Implementing and interpreting the standard may require technical expertise.

Overreliance on audits

On-chain audit representation should differ from comprehensive security practices.

Standardization adoption

Widespread adoption by auditors and developers is crucial for maximizing impact.

Auditor Identification

The proposal focuses on firms rather than individual auditors, raising concerns about accountability and reputation.

Static Audits vs. Evolving Security

New vulnerabilities emerge, requiring mechanisms to reflect ongoing security assessments.

Contract vs. Protocol Scope

Differentiating between individual contracts and overall protocol audits is crucial for accurate assessments.

Intra-Contract Scope

Incomplete audits due to budget constraints necessitate clear communication of unreviewed functionalities.

“Audited” vs. “Passed”

Distinguishing between completed audits and those with unaddressed findings is essential for avoiding misplaced trust.

Proxy Handling

Proxies are prevalent in Ethereum, creating complexities for on-chain audits. The proposal grapples with representing underlying implementation code using either deploymentCode or runtimeCode, each with its advantages and drawbacks.

Conclusion

ERC-7512 presents a significant step towards enhanced security and transparency. Including essential audit metadata, such as individual auditor identification, dynamic updates, scope parameters, and auditor confidence, would further strengthen the proposal. Collaboration within the community is crucial to refining and effectively implementing this innovative standard.

The proposed standard represents a significant step towards enhancing smart contract security and transparency in DeFi. Bringing audit information on-chain in a standardized format opens doors for automated verification, improved user experience, and a more robust security ecosystem. While challenges remain, collaborative efforts within the Ethereum community can pave the way for its successful implementation.

About Olympix

Olympix is a pioneering DevSecOps tool that puts security in the hands of the developer by proactively securing code from day one.

Join our beta program to fortify your smart contracts and proactively shield them from exploits in the evolving Web3 security landscape.

Connect with us on: